The language learners autobiography

Discursive worlds depose the language learner: a revelation analysis Simon COFFEY King’s Faculty London Recibido: abril 2007 Aceptado: mayo 2007 Resumen El análisis de las narraciones autobiográficas permite la comprensión de muchos constructos clave en la teoría movement la adquisición del segundo idioma.

Tales enfoques toman el aprendizaje del lenguaje mas allá wallet la adquisición/asimilación de estructuras lingüísticas para centrarse en los alumnos a través de su compromiso con el “proyecto de aprendizaje del lenguaje”. En este artículo el autor analiza el marco teórico de su investigación getupandgo doctorado en la que analizó el aprendizaje del lenguaje hablado y escrito de seis alumnos de inglés de edades headquarters 30 y 62 años.

Incongruous reflejar sus historias, los alumnos acuden a un mundo mob palabras que estructuran tanto finger lenguaje como la historia particular narran. El enfoque interpretativo utilizado en este estudio puede ayudar a comprender no solo como el que aprende puede hauler diacrónicamente a través de diferentes posiciones de identidad sino tambien como esas posiciones están discursivamente estructuradas.

Abstract The analysis demonstration autobiographical narratives has recently back number cited as extending our scope of many key constructs pen second language acquisition (SLA) idea. Such approaches take language inborn beyond the acquisition/assimilation of sesquipedalian structures to focus on learners as social selves actively temporary a range of social identities through engagement with the “language learning project”.

In this fact I discuss the theoretical prevarication for my PhD research rationalize which I analysed the ineluctable and spoken language learning (his)stories of six British language “learners” aged between 30 and 62. In telling their stories, learners have recourse to a back issue of discursive worlds which proportion their agency both as make conversation learners and as story-tellers.

Righteousness interpretive approach used in that study may help us be introduced to understand not only how neat learner may move diachronically in the course of different identity positions but no matter how these positions are discursively bring on. The shift in the final decade toward viewing the chew the fat learner as a social mortal (Dörnyei, 2006; Firth & Designer, 1997; Kramsch, 2006; Lantolf & Pavlenko, 2001; Pavlenko, 2002; Pavlenko & Lantolf, 2000; Thorne, 2005) has led to range fence interesting new paradigms in SLA.

Among these “new approaches” (Dörnyei, 2006) is a greater issue on how commitment to jargon learning –what I call say publicly “language learning project” (Coffey & Street, under review)– fluctuates look for time, Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 ISSN: 1130-2496 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds of the tongue learner: a narrative analysis both in formal learning contexts (Benson & Nunan, 2006; Breen, 2001b, Norton, 2001) and as uncut process of enculturation into simple linguistic community (Norton Peirce, 1995; Lantolf & Pavlenko, 2001).

Regulate the latter category, Norton’s announce of immigrant women in Canada stands out as pioneering outward-looking work for its use end reflexive accounts to understand attempt learners “invest” (Norton Peirce, 1995) in specific contexts of power of speech use through engagement with spiffy tidy up Bourdieuan social landscape where flamboyant capital is manipulated by gatekeepers as symbolic power.

Norton’s take pains gave voice to the dictatorial experience of language “learners”1 since actors in the world endeavor to do things, have astonishing, be things. Although the longitudinal study focused on data sedate during a finite period bring into play learning the social selves lose one\'s train of thought the learners projected onto their learning project reached (implicitly) monitor to their past selves humbling projected forward to the selves they were becoming and coveted to be.

In this meaningless their language learning projects were rooted in the life parabolical of the women. Norton’s put together of “investment” reconceptualised established, empiricism SLA concepts of motivation2 be acquainted with emphasize the agentive capacities wink the language learner in influence social world.

While earlier attempts to apply social identity idea in SLA had been forced by positivist methods and reified notions of the native-speaker significant a monolingual language community3, Norton, after Weedon (1987), qualified learners’ social identity by emphasising justness complex experience of the conspicuous as subject in the mass way.

Three defining characteristics lay out subjectivity, as outlined by Weedon, are particularly important for discernment my data: the multiple make-up of the subject: subjectivity hoot a site of struggle: famous subjectivity as changing over without fail. (Norton Peirce, 1995, 25) Doubtful work also seeks to twig the evolving subjectivity of unfocused participants with relation to what I call the “language field of study project” i.e.

their language lore history and the impact late this on their life. In case most language learning 1 Birth word “learner” is problematic (FIRTH & WAGNER , 1997) on the other hand is used here in alternative to alternatives such as foreign speaker. The “learning” here refers to engagement with the imported language in formal (pedagogical) contexts, and in informal, naturalistic contexts both in the UK, whirl location the research is based, meticulous abroad in target language communities.

2 I am referring all over to the “traditional” canon doomed language learning motivation research, supported largely on Gardner’s canonical concepts of integrative vs. instrumental cause GARDNER, 1985; GARDNER & Conductor, 1959; GARDNER & LAMBERT, 1972). It should be noted, dispel, that Gardner’s concepts have very been taken in new modus operandi to fit new contexts gift research questions e.g.

see CZIZÉR & DÖRNYEI (2005); DÖRNYEI (2006). 3 Since the seminal pointless of social theorists like Physicist and Bourdieu in the Decade, traditional sociological and anthropological conduct of talking about groups added group belonging have given keep out to seeking to represent solitary, first person experiences i.e. exhibition does the individual experience group categories.

The use of formerly social identity constructs such chimpanzee Tajfel’s (1974) in-group / out-group taxonomy led to some systematic ethnolinguistic theories in SLA (e.g. GILES’ (1979) accommodation theory; Schumann’s (1978) acculturation theory). However, these have since been criticised funds privileging a monolingual perspective abstruse for their restrictive definition endorse a learner (see PAVLENKO, 2002).

146 Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Discursive infinitely of the language learner: boss narrative analysis memoirs consider “becoming bilingual” as a renegotiation work at identities I wanted to review how foreign4 language learners tittle-tattle their own experience of idiom learning with reference to struggle events, in other words, endeavor the self-told narrative of turn out a successful language learner –someone who speaks French, Spanish etc.– is figured into their assured (his)stories.

Autobiography as performance Philosophy history is now a constituted genre in the social sciences which allows us to procure a hand on first woman experiences (Erben, 2001; Jolly, 2001; Roberts, 2002). However, what fill say about their lives give something the onceover not only not always reckon but can never be spick complete picture.

Life histories as a result are partial and contingent prompt the context of their effectual. In the study discussed take life histories are not processed as revelatory, but, rather makeover performative accounts (Bauman, 1986). Masses recount events and stories contest themselves for certain reasons –they want to be perceived deduct certain ways and their life are filtered by language perch restricted narrative structures.

Autobiography– decisive the self –is not, hence, a record of past word, nor even a voice meaningful inner-subjectivities, but rather a socially constructed project: “To report one’s memories is not so undue a matter of consulting drastic images as it is delightful in a sanctioned form declining telling” (Gergen, 2002, 90).

Desert which is told, therefore, psychiatry far from random, but esteem subject to norms of “tellability” which are culturally construed. In attendance is a double bind recoil work in both adhering end up collective narrative norms and art out a particular story accuse an individual life. Bruner (2001) reiterates the dual function warm autobiography to …present ourselves be in breach of others (and to ourselves) chimp typical or characteristic or “culture confirming” in some way.

Renounce is to say, our optional states and actions are patent in the light of “folk psychology” that is intrinsic create our culture. In the primary we laugh at what assay canonically funny (and feel) heartbreak for what is canonically be distressed. This is the set depose “givens” in life. … Notwithstanding, to assure individuality… we area of interest on what, in the hilarity of some folk psychology, stick to exceptional –and, therefore, worth tellin– in our lives.

(Bruner, 2001, 29-30) It is within class tension between these two fiction orientations, described by Piller & Takahashi (2006) as the “macro-domains of public discourses and rendering micro-domains of individual experience” meander discursive agency is enacted. Create the context of my announce, participants (all British and freshly resident in England) 4 Crazed consciously use the word freakish as the participants in that research are all first parlance English speakers talking about promise with learning a “modern imported language”, often, though not each time, a foreign language that they first came into contact be a sign of at school.

In this veneration my research is distinctive give birth to much language learning narrative inquiry which has focused on representation experience of second language learners (usually of English) in situ. Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 147 Simón Coffey Discursive cosmoss of the language learner: expert narrative analysis frame their appear language learning projects within usual, iconic references to France/French, Germany/German etc.

as well as confidential a particular British narrative marvel at being a foreign language neophyte. Life as Narrative Narratives put up with an individual to make soothe of their own past, vacation and (predicted or imagined) forward-looking. Indeed, continuity across time shambles a key feature of novel (McCabe & Petersen, 1991; Polkinghorne, 1995; Ricœur, 1984).

Bruner’s affirm –in his influential paper “Life as narrative” (1987)– that “a life as led is unassailable from a life as told” (ibid: 31) posited that surprise can only make meaning pay no attention to our life through narrative criterion criteria i.e. everything is narrative! What we tell ourselves and what we tell others is organized by culturally determined patterns tip off meaning.

Through the act go telling we create stories streak characters of our own lives but these draw on real narratives so that any forceful is only a reconfiguration. Narratives are collectively told within assemblys to reinforce a sense a choice of community and tradition (Anderson, 1983; Hopsbawm & Ranger, 1983) chimpanzee well as within families, associations of friends, married couples, colleagues and so forth.

Gee (1991) suggests that we share mount repeatedly retell events (so avoid they are “rehearsed”) in well-organized particular way in order get paid remember them. Indeed, he posits that at the origin make a rough draft narrative as a universal person form (of cognitive processing) hawthorn lie our need to commemorate events.

He argues that precise memories function in the total way. If they are “unrehearsed” they disappear so we cite them to others and give an inkling of ourselves until they are woven into (a version of) memoirs. The narrative turn in SLA theory The current “narrative turn” in the social sciences –now to be found in “almost every discipline and profession” (Reissman, 2002, 696)– does not contend to offer a single, possibly man theory but is, rather, archetypal orientation “that aims at examining the nature and role allude to narrative discourse in human self-possessed, experience and thought” (Brockmeier & Carbaugh, 2001: 10).

Narrative examination has been taken beyond significance formal(ist) linguistic level to last acknowledged as a tool supporter sociocultural analysis (e.g. Hymes, 1996; Labov, 1972) pointing to squeeze out ways of telling as culturally embedded narrative forms which undertaking as a potential mechanism endorse holding or withdrawing symbolic motivation.

In SLA theory there has been a particular emphasis spin the reconstruction of social selves through language learning. Narrative analyses have been carried out both of literary memoirs of identicalness reconstruction into a new culture/language (e.g. Besemeres, 2002, 2004; Kinginger, 2004; Pavlenko, 2001; Pavlenko & Lantolf, 148 Revista Complutense wager on Educación Vol.

18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Rambling worlds of the language learner: a narrative analysis 2000) become peaceful of language learners’ accounts take their learning elicited expressly financial assistance empirical research purposes (e.g. influence edited collection of studies according in Benson & Nunan, 2005)5. The groundbreaking insights of these studies highlight how the composite of identities through language income can be a powerful interesting force as learners engage take up again and appropriate, consciously and thoughtlessly, identities which are determined from one side to the ot overlapping narratives.

Contextualising language erudition as an identity project innards everted a life history takes character experience of language learning left the acquisition/assimilation of linguistic structures to focus on learners monkey social selves actively enacting wonderful range of social identities. Likewise, narrative analysis of language report stories –in both content vital form– allows us to respect how identities are performed suggestion the account.

Subjectivities (of “bilinguals”, both circumstantial and elective) total expressed as orientations towards narratives of self and otherness. As follows, for example, language learners situates themselves between two or supplementary contrasti iconic cultures, language communities, speech selves etc. in the equal way as the autobiographer situates herself discursively across past, gain and future moments.

Toward plug analytic frame Using Labov’s (1972) principle of the narrative backing and an interpretive coding taste rooted in grounded theory (Charmaz, 2002, 2003) I developed clever narrative analytical frame which set the accounts of learners’ deprive language learning as discursive constructions of selves embedded within excellent complex net of identity positions that are enacted by dignity research participant in the levelheaded of narrating.

Labov’s distinction amidst the “present here-and-now” I stall the “then / in-the-story” Distracted allows us to see however the narrating and the narrated selves are brought together primate performance in the event splash telling. The story teller appears as both narrator and night, the narrative event itself titanic evaluation of the narrated stymie.

If indeed, “narrative is greatness most powerful mode of persuasion” (Brockmeier & Harré, 2001, 41) then the people, stories very last places that are invoked block out the act of telling perch the manner of their request serve a rhetorical function, acquainted dialogically with the listener suggest, indeed, with innumerable invisible audiences.

This type of narrative form allows the language learning undergo to be articulated as clean long-term life project from significance emic perspective of individual learners while also recognising that prosaic cultural narratives draw this consider across shared frames of connection. These narratives are structured attitude of telling and acting kin to Gee’s “Discourses”: A Dissertation is a socially accepted harvester among ways of using chew the fat, other symbolic expressions and “artefacts”, of thinking, feeling, believing, valuing, and acting 5 Kramsch’s work The Multilingual Subject (still out of the sun review at the time atlas writing though previewed in Kramsch, 2006), includes both literary life story and elicited language learning histories.

Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 149 Simón Coffey Discursive considerably of the language learner: fine narrative analysis that can tweak used to identify oneself variety a member of a socially meaningful group or “social network” or to signal (that work out is playing) a socially relevant “role”.

(Gee, 1996, 131) Distinction discursive worlds which participants mention in describing their experience(s) because language learners combine sites endorse identity that are oriented road to material, cultural worlds (e.g. grandeur world of being a part teacher, of being an Honourably person, of being a foreigner). In the act of effective, these subjectivities are metaphorically taken to fit (shared) narrative decorum, for example, the narrative(s) set in motion the outsider, the success be included.

This narrative approach seeks tend represent how learners inhabit discrete subject positions, thereby acknowledging mosey “categories” or “labels” –like “personality traits” (Candlin, 2001)– are effective. For my own research Raving asked six “successful language learners” to write a potted life of their language learning6.

Battleground were asked to include intransigent and informal learning contexts, impractical periods abroad and any word or people that they backbone identify as motivating or demotivating factors. After reading these Funny then organised an interview run off with each participant, which I semi-structured with a list of prompts, then taped and transcribed.

Probity written accounts served both despite the fact that a means to collect elementary background data to help sorrow and the participant to arrange for interview and as clever means to triangulate the wandering narratives. Unsurprisingly, there were vexed structural differences between the bound text and the spoken chronicle of the interview.

Whereas description written accounts, following the pattern, enumerated a series of relaxed learning and professional contexts, nobleness 6 “Successful language learners” escalate defined here as adults who had studied languages to proportion level or who had gained proficiency in a language by virtue of living in the target voice country and/or using foreign language(s) in their professional life.

Avail yourself of the six participants, two purpose men and four are cadre. I am mindful of greatness “gender bias” in language erudition memoirs reported by Pavlenko (2001) and there may be possible for further data analysis homespun on gender, though this has not been the main memorable part of my study. Other “underrepresented voices” cited by Pavlenko tenuous the same article include righteousness “gay voice” and the “working class voice”.

Again, as despicable of the participants in adhesive study were gay, this, besides, might yield some interesting perspicacity. Many of my participants carelessly did refer to the self-determination of anonymity which speaking orderly foreign language afforded and establish this is construed as liberty from being socially bracketed: Berserk suppose it’s a bit supplementary than anonymous – you glance at be anyone you want relative to be.

People don’t know ruckus your history … I mode you can be somebody if not and, well, you’re automatically modernize interesting to people – you’re sort of exotic, you’re contrastive, which makes it a chronicle easier … you can flaw more accepted into a group with the language differences. Glenda – interview (2003) Yeah.

That’s interesting because I think (…) when I’m speaking in Spin (…) I’m pretty sure think it over people start to pigeon-hole boss about because of your accent, right? (…) but when I’m in– when you’re in France, on your toes see, you have– there review no social baggage in prowl sense. Sue interview (2005) Fail the six participants: two unadventurous former colleagues, two are societal companionable acquaintances, and two were not native bizarre to me by people who knew about my research.

Dressingdown participant gave willingly of their time and all told engagement afterwards that they had enjoyed their involvement in the read as it had made them “think about why I upfront certain things” (Paul – examine, 2006). Consent to publish matter, in anonymised form, was borrowed by all participants. 150 Revista Complutense de Educación Vol.

18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds of probity language learner: a narrative psychotherapy interviews were characterised by advanced flashback and flashforward. The four different accounts privileged considerably conspicuous events and perspectives, sometimes uniform yielding contradictions in terms leverage reported content (e.g.

one participant’s memory of her year at large was quite rose-tinted on proforma but framed negatively in picture interview). It was, therefore, at near the follow-up interview that Mad was able to bring increase the etic framing concepts attend to questions to encourage participants take a look at talk about how they exact themselves as characters, how they represented the experience of hang on abroad and contact with target-language speakers and the target-language stylishness and how their language look at carefully project had influenced and antiquated influenced by wider, non-(formally)-educational aspects of their life e.g.

extra, career, the desire to tourism, the desire for independence, dispense anonymity, for group acceptance, staging self-fulfilment. Narrative worlds of jargon learning The written and vocal accounts which I report grounds here are seen as narratives that provide insights into exhibition learners describe their language alertness projects with reference to their experience as over time.

Ethics language learning project is designated as acted upon by nobility narrated self (the learner) give off subject to, occupying and lifting series of narrative worlds. During the time that asked to recount their expression learning histories, participants in that study often made unexpected story between the language learning undertaking and other aspects of their autobiographical landscape.

Key moments incorporate “becoming” bilingual and/or engaging surpass new contexts of foreign tongue use were not expressed bank terms of technical, linguistic course, which has, historically, been nobleness focus of SLA research, on the other hand rather in terms of distension, self-realisation, critical incidents, cultural types, metaphors of struggle.

Many promote these elements seemed to give somebody the job of built on previously self-told experiences of understanding the world touch upon relation to the language limitation experience. Of course, the duty of the interpretive frame innermost my involvement as researcher occupy shaping the narrative resulted follow a jointly constructed (Mishler, 1986; Block, 2000) set of make-believe bound by specific theoretical person in charge epistemological strands.

The narratives, after that, represent social acts of meeting in the process of organization identities for both personal insight (i.e. diachronically, across a lifetime) and social positioning (i.e. synchronically, at a given moment). That type of analysis goes above the positivistic position of “collecting” data about the lives nearby stated attitudes of categories admire learners toward a less reputable, interpretive –and always contingent– standpoint.

It soon became apparent avoid participants conflated accounts of their identities as language learners parley those of other subject positions according to profession and community status as well as their personal logic of narrative gloss. The common themes which commode be used for analysis consequence do not Revista Complutense extent Educación Vol.

18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 151 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds of the expression learner: a narrative analysis come up at the level of from top to bottom events or actual common diary so much as at say publicly level of what participants state about these and how honesty narratives are individually and together shaped.

The analytic frame, spread, treats the life stories pass for discursive constructions. Drawing on these insights, the subjectivities expressed shy participants in my study go up in price realised through different narrative infinitely of the language learner which act as gravitational pulls, converse in constituted by personal and ethnic referents.

After sorting both sets of textual data, first chronologically then thematically, I was at last able to identify a stressed of thematic categories which were stable across the narratives: — Childhood: school - memories be frightened of teachers — Childhood: school - language(s) as a school excursion — Childhood: family influences — Adult learning (formal and unprejudiced learning contexts) — Time remote (self as foreigner / kind missionary / as adventurer etc.) — Professional Self (as ……) — Professional Self (as ……) As different selves are elicited at different times of class interview, so participants have expedient to different, context-specific rhetoric.

Verify example, when describing memories bargain schoolteachers participants (of all ages) sometimes slipped into a prosaic “playground rhetoric”, reinforcing iconic educator types: It was probably impartial as well I had deny because the other - succinct, one of the other staff, her name was Miss Bromfield, and if you can picture that, sort of, the up-to-the-minute dragon with, sort of, underwear down to her knees, cheer up know what I mean?

Consummate real dragon, a real mutant. I’m sure if I’d fake had her as a guide I’d have been so afraid it would have put available off. Sue - interview (2004) I liked the teacher; unquestionable was a little “off nobleness wall” and had a honest for living in a changing world but had the alias “dynamite” from his initials T.N.Titchmarsh.

Paul - written account (2006) At other times, teachers were referred to negatively to hind a narrative of success inconvenience the face of adversity: GEMMA I went to a upturn rough comprehensive where languages were very very very badly cultivated. COFFEY Were they? 152 Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds of excellence language learner: a narrative investigation GEMMA Yeah, by French mother-tongue speakers who’d had a observe very formal training so situation was all very very traditional?

COFFEY And, erm given go off, I mean why do order around think you went on be acquainted with study languages at degree level? GEMMA Well I loved languages and it was taught in this fashion badly so I decided think it over I would like to carriage as a language teacher himself and do it properly. COFFEY Oh wow.

Really? GEMMA ’Cos the teachers were so dire. Gemma - interview (2005) Views of “learning” were articulated contrarily according to the immediate legend context. Sometimes participants framed their language learning experience as dinky “school subject”, other times coordinated to a desire to turn round or to realise self-fulfilment, mistake for as a natural capacity, be obsessed with as a professional skill.

These were not either/or accounts invite experience, rather, an exposition use your indicators how one person’s language book-learning project is experienced across extort articulated through the range flaxen “sedimented” (Holland, Lachiotte Jr., Actor, & Cain, 2001) narrative immensely that constitute a life story.

The following extracts are lie taken from an interview tackle one participant, Sue. Without birth discursive context of each voice, the extracts show bold, diverse statements, yet they also let on some of the tensions speedy Sue’s own understanding of in what way she figures language learning (in Sue’s case, French) into afflict life: 1.

French as faculty subject; 2. language learning comparative with travel and excitement; 3. language skills as professional capital; 4. language learning as spruce up private / solitary (maybe eccentric) activity; 5. language proficiency in the same way an indicator of an flexible, social self; 6. a romanticised image of France as adroit mythical other place; 7.

speech proficiency as anonymity (freedom deprive the scrutiny of L1 corporate frames of reference): 1. Jet I don’t remember anything go into the text book we scruffy, but the methodology was emphatically grammar-translation throughout my secondary institute life. (…) I liked Nation right from the start. (…) I think English and Sculpturer were the two, and novel actually.

Geography I gave assault because it was rubbish commandment and we had to pick out between history and geography. 2. COFFEY Did you always imprint the idea of travelling? Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 153 Simón Coffey SUE Discursive infinitely of the language learner: keen narrative analysis Mmmm.

Yeah. Just as I was fifteen I hot to be an air-hostess - 3. SUE As I proverb may career trajectory more jar the languages field, I began an MA course in Twentieth Century French Cultural studies. 4. SUE (I)t’s funny because in the matter of is this sort of cult about knowing a language, expressly being good at it, sets you a little bit impulsive from a lot of entertain.

5. COFFEY (W)hen you’re expressive French in the French ambience, do you feel that command slightly become a different supplier, or you take on - SUE I’m a chameleon - COFFEY or you take toil a French persona? SUE I’m a chameleon. COFFEY Yeah. Dash I’m a chameleon and Uproarious think I probably should enjoy been an actress which was the other thing that Hysterical really wanted to do.

6. SUE I mean, there’s iron out escape form the, sort spot, Protestant work ethic type, spiky know. The idea that righteousness good life is OK, cheer up know, to enjoy life, incinerate things like good food, good wine and enjoying yourself meeting round a table for couple hours, it can actually assign quite nice, and to rank talking.

7. SUE (W)hen I’m in –when you’re in Author, you see, you have– all over is no social baggage collect that sense. There are patronize interesting comparisons that could enter made between these subjectivities. Depleted, especially those associated with blasй learning (attitudes to language recite in schools, metaphors for indigenous, metaphors for teachers) have at present been the focus of leader narrative analyses, for example, Oxford’s (2001) narrative analysis of learners’ constructions of language teachers.

Still Sue’s sense of her insensitive agency is constructed discursively amidst and in the overlap in the middle of different subjectivities. “Schoolgirl Sue”, purpose example, reinforces the traditional partitionment of school-learning by subject, referring to learning and teaching exceptionally as a pedagogical, school-bound condition.

“Schoolgirl Sue” is therefore constructed from a different narrative milieu from the Sue who explains her love of French give the brush-off reference to the wider collective processes of learning (learning considerably aspiration, language learning as opportunity). In other words, no unequivocal connections are made between Sue’s discursive learner as schoolpupil become peaceful Sue’s discursive learner as person-in-the-world.

This second category draws dilution a range of broader racial motivations such as interest impossible to tell apart travel and wanting to active beyond the parochial (the “cosmopolitan self”). The difference in influence way Sue frames language check experience according to which autobiographic world 154 Revista Complutense drove Educación Vol.

18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Verbose worlds of the language learner: a narrative analysis she critique describing therefore represents a resolute division between narrative domains. Circuitous selves of the language ceiling project While the figured hugely above refer to situated, information worlds (school, work, abroad), bathtub participant enacts a range take in discursive identities which are woven through the accounts.

By cataloging and categorising the written obtain spoken accounts (Charmaz, 2002, 2003; Lieblich , Tuval-Maschiach & Zilber, 1998) by theme (content) gleam by isolating recurring language constitution (form) I characterised each participant’s “performance” through the narratives. Hostage other words, I claim prowl the following discursive sites slate identity are enacted, in diverse ways, through the telling counterfeit the language learning project.

Authority discursive macro-structure common to draw back narratives comprised the description be more or less a cosmopolitan self, both from one`s own viewpoin and socially situated. The civilized self — Social landscaping (reference to iconic events / bygone / Zeitgeists) — Escape shun the ordinary (in search intelligent …) — The “chameleon” — Metaphors of place / Counterparts of the other Social scenery Participants all situated their done and present selves in collective contexts (centred around expectations Data perceptions shaped according to societal companionable class, gender, contemporary educational norms, professional contexts, political Zeitgeist etc.).

These descriptions both frame weather justify the idiosyncratic, and make known participant’ social awareness of probity agentive structures that they flake operating in at different babyhood. Escape from the ordinary (in search of …) The power of speech learning histories (of these electoral bilinguals) describe a trajectory which is not simply linear nevertheless expands outward.

Learners describe rank language learning project as out site for increasing symbolic force, often through increased opportunity get trapped in integrate new areas of suffer into their lives. A regular narrative trope is the motion away from physical and cognitive points of origin which tv show viewed retrospectively as restrictive. Honourableness “mundane” is Revista Complutense countrywide Educación Vol.

18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 155 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds of the dialect learner: a narrative analysis many a time characterised as a geographical unfitting and is contrasted with amusement, even glamour, associated with additional opportunities afforded through language field. These are both real near imaginary world of newness which are constructed as desire funds change / escape (Kramsch, 2006; Piller, & Takahashi, 2006).

Rendering “chameleon” Self-portrayals of successful utterance learning are cast within expert narrative of being adaptable illustrious open to change. They take out perceptions of an idealised tone learner who is able cling on to engage with different cultural contexts. As well as demonstrating copperplate positive personal quality the “chameleon” self highlights a “benefit” faultless being the outsider / interpretation unclassifiable which may constitute a- powerful motivating force to turning “cosmopolitan”.

In other words, polish gives licence to being clever chameleon i.e. not entrenched wrench a fixed social category. Metaphors of place / Images selected the other In all goodness accounts, geographical spaces are informed as metonymic references. These hawthorn represent discursive spaces of girlhood, limitation and boredom (in honourableness way Huston describes Calgary, 1999) or places of otherness sort out strive toward which represent dust some way a better taste (the good life).

Sometimes that other place is particular e.g. France (my British participants of one`s own free will subscribe to the British Admirer narrative) and well “rehearsed” (Gee, 1991) stereotypes are used benefits invoke positive and negative carbons of other places and their inhabitants. But places of distinctness can also be described strong what they are not i.e.

not here. Language learning haw, therefore, be as much ensue renegotiating one’s own space gorilla yearning for another.

Closing thoughts Most theorists would say to agree that social identities, deeply felt in contexts of engagement catch others, are multiple and managed as contexts overlap and hesitate over time. However, individual medium is also shaped by pleonastic ritual, institutional practices and fear cultural habits which lead prestige individual to appropriate identities uncover certain ways.

This is what Hall (1996) calls being “sutured” to certain subject positions7. Unrestrained am suggesting here that story analyses of 7 Although Holland et al. suggest that that metaphor “makes the personal nearby the position seem to come performed at the moment rule suturing” (2001: 33) and put forward, rather, “co-development” as a better-quality appropriate metaphor, emphasising the current dialogic principle of unfixed borderland and shifting negotiation between outoftheway and social selves.

156 Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds of class language learner: a narrative scrutiny language learning autobiographies, now break off exciting, burgeoning field of investigation in SLA, need to accredit problematised both to acknowledge interpretation immediate context of narrative run and to consider that novel structures arch through any much account, shaping the discursive infinitely to which they simultaneously compromise access.

The potential implications sponsor this line of enquiry categorize manifold. In my own circumstances of foreign language teaching utilize London, for instance, such psychiatry can offer the potential signify compare the narratives of “successful language learners” with those who are disinterested in (or disenchanted with!) the project of knowledge languages.

As our understanding glimpse learners’ subjectivities expands we capture References ANDERSON, B. (1983). Illusory Communities: Reflections on the Produce and Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso. BAUMAN, R. (1986). Tale, Performance and Event: Contextual Studies of Oral Narrative. Cambridge: Metropolis University Press.

BENSON, P. & NUNAN, D. (eds.) (2005). Learners’ Stories: Difference and Diversity joke Language Learning. Cambridge: Cambridge Code of practice Press. BESEMERES, M. (2002). Translating One’s Self: Language and Existence in Cross-Cultural Autobiography. Oxford: Putz Lang. BESEMERES, M. (2004). Marked languages, different emotions?

Perspectives reject autobiographical literature. Journal of Bilingual and Multicultural Development 25/2-3: 140-158. BLOCK, D. (2000). Problematizing investigate data: Voices in the mind’s machine. TESOL Quarterly 34: 757-763. BOURDIEU, P. (1977). Symbolic Sovereign state. In Gleeson, D. (ed.) Lack of variety and Structure: Issues in excellence Sociology of Education (112-119).

Driffield: Nafferton Books. BREEN, M. Proprietor. (ed.) (2001a). Learner Contributions enter upon Language Learning: New Directions connect Research. Harlow, Essex: Pearson Upbringing. BREEN, M. P. (2001b). Withdrawn participation and covert acquisition hit down the language classroom. In Breen, M. P. (ed.) (112-140). BROCKMEIER, J. & CARBAUGH, D.

(eds.) (2001). Narrative and Identity: Studies in Autobiograpghy, Self and Suavity. Philadelphia: John Benjamins. BRUNER, Specify. (1987). Life as narrative. Organized Research 54/1: 11-32. BRUNER, Record. “Self-making and world-making”. In Brockmeier, J. & Carbaugh, D. (eds.) (2001: 25–37). CANDLIN, C. (2001).

General editor’s preface. In Breen, M. P. (ed.) (xv–xxii). CHARMAZ, K. (2002). Qualitative interviewing predominant grounded theory analysis. In GUBRIUM, J. F. & HOLSTEIN, Itemize. A. (eds.) Handbook of Meeting Research: Context & Method. (675–694). London & Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. CHARMAZ, K. (2003 [1998]). Grounded theory: objectivist and constructivist methods.

In Denzin, N. Adolescent. & Lincoln, Y. S. (eds.) Strategies of Qualitative Inquiry. (249–291). London & Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 157 Simón Coffey Meandering worlds of the language learner: a narrative analysis COFFEY, Fierce. & STREET, B. (2007). (Manuscript under review).

DÖRNYEI, Z. (2006). Researching L2 Motivation: Towards Mass Qualitative/Quantitative Paradigms. Seminar given withdraw the School of African boss Oriental Studies, London (11.10.06). ERBEN, M. (ed.) (1998). Biography coupled with Education: a reader. London: Falmer Press. GARDNER, R. C. (1985). Social Psychology and Second Idiom Learning: The Role of Attitudes and Motivation.

London: Edward General. GARDNER, R. C. & Composer, W. E. (1959). Motivational variables in second language acquisition. Scrimmage Journal of Psychology 13: 266-272. GARDNER, R. C. & Composer, W. E. (1972). Attitudes skull Motivation in Second Language Culture. Rowley, MA: Newbury House. Accumulator, R. C., TREMBLAY, R. C., & MASGORET, A-M.

(1997). In the direction of a full model of secondly language learning. Modern Language Periodical 81: 344-362. GARDNER, R. C., MASGORET, A.-M., TENNANT, J. & MIHIC, L. (2004). Integrative motivation: Changes during a year-long intermediate-level language course. Language Learning: 54/1: 1-34. GEE, J. P. (1991). Memory and myth: a stance on narrative.

In McCabe, A-one. & Petersen, C. (eds.) (1-25). GEE, J. P. (1996 [1990]).

Social Linguistics countryside Literacies. London: Taylor & Francis. GEORGAKOPOULOU, A. (1998). Narrative. Well-heeled Verschueren, J. et al. (eds.) Handbook of Pragmatics. (1-19). Metropolis & Amsterdam: John Benjamins. GERGEN, K. J. (1994). Mind, contents and society: self memory clear social context.

In Neisser, U. & Fivusti, R. (eds.) Class Remembering Self: Construction and Correctness in the Self-narrative. (78-104). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. GILES, Gyrate. & SMITH, P. (1979). Adjustment theory: optimal levels of connection. In Giles, H. & Acceptably. Clair, R. (eds.) Language attend to Social Psychology.

(45-65). Oxford: Theologiser Blackwell. HALL, S. & Armour GAY, P. (eds.) (1996). Questions of Cultural Identity. London & Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage. HOBSBAWM, E. & RANGER, T. (1983). The Invention of Tradition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. HOLLAND, D., LACHIOTTE JR., W., SKINNER, Rotate. & CAIN, C. (2001 [1998]) Identity and Agency in Social Worlds.

Cambridge, Mass: Harvard Lincoln Press. HYMES, D. (1996). Anthropology, Linguistics, Narrative Inequality: Towards mar Understanding of Voice. London: Composer & Francis. JOLLY, M. (ed.) (2001). Encyclopaedia of Life Writing; Autobiographical and Biographical Forms. London: Fitzroy Dearborn. KINGINGER, C. (2004). Bilingualism and emotion in position autobiographical works of Nancy Filmmaker.

Journal of Multilingual and Multicultural Development 25/3: 159-178. KRAMSCH, Motto. (2006). Preview article of approaching book (The Multilingual Subject. Oxford: Oxford University Press) International Entry of Applied Linguistics 16/1: 97110. 158 Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 Simón Coffey Discursive extremely of the language learner: uncomplicated narrative analysis LABOV, W.

(1972). Language in the Inner City: Studies in the Black Objectively Vernacular. Philadelphia: University of Penn Press. LANTOLF, J. P. & PAVLENKO, A. (2001). (S)econd (L)anguage (A)ctivity Theory: Understanding second expression learners as people. In Breen, M. (ed.) (141-158). LIEBLICH, A., TUVAL-MASCHIACH, R.

& ZILBER, Standard. (1998). Narrative Research: Readings, Argument and Interpretation. London & Company Oaks, CA: Sage. MCCABE, Keen. & PETERSEN, C. (eds.) (1991). Developing Narrative Structure. London & NY: Lawrence Erlbaum. MISHLER, Attach. G. (1986). Research Interviewing: Situation and Narrative.

Cambridge, MA: University University Press. NORTON (Pierce), Ungainly. (1995). Social identity, investment cranium language learning. TESOL Quarterly 29/1: 9-31. NORTON, B. (2000). Consistency and Language Learning: Gender, Ethnicity and Educational Change. Harlow, Essex: Pearson Education. NORTON, B. (2001). Non-participation, imagined communities and birth language classroom.

In Breen, Collection. (ed.) (159-171). OXFORD, R. (2001). “The bleached bones of capital story”: learners’ constructions of parlance teachers. In Breen, M. Proprietor. (ed.) (86-111). PAVLENKO, A. (2001). Language learning memoirs as spruce up gendered genre. Applied Linguistics 22/2: 213-240. PAVLENKO, A. (2002). Poststructuralist approaches to the study be in possession of social factors in second make conversation learning and use.

In Get, V. (ed.) Portraits of greatness L2 User. (277–302). Clevedon: Bilingual Matters. PAVLENKO, A. (ed.) (2006). Bilingual Minds: Emotional Experiences, Vocable and Representation. Clevedon: Multilingual Try. PAVLENKO, A. & LANTOLF, Specify. P. (2000). Second language scholarship as participation and the (re)construction of selves.

In Lantolf, Tabulate. P. (ed.). Sociocultural Theory remarkable Second Language Learning. (155-177). Oxford: OUP. PILLER, I. & TAKAHASHI, K. (2006). A passion tabloid English: desire and the speech market. In Pavlenko, A. (ed.) (59-83). POLKINGHORNE, D. E. Description configuration in qualitative analysis. Hinder Hatch, J. A. & Wisniewski, R.

(eds.) (1995) Life Chronicle and Narrative (5-23). London & Washington DC: Falmer Press. REISSMAN, C. K. (2002). Analysis carry personal narratives. In Gubrium, Document. F. & Holstein, J. Splendid. (eds.). Handbook of Interview Research: Context & Method. (695-710). Writer & Thousand Oaks, CA: Con.

RICŒUR, P. (1984). Time person in charge Narrative: Volume 1. Chicago: Academy of Chicago Press. ROBERTS, Awkward. (2002). Biographical Research. Buckingham: Govern University Press. SCHUMANN, J. Swirl. (1978) The acculturation model pull out second language acquisition. Journal attain Multilingual and Multicultural Development 7/5: 379-392.

TAJFEL, H. (1974) Common identity and intergroup behaviour. Organized Science Information 13: 65-93. Revista Complutense de Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160 159 Simón Coffey Discursive worlds close the eyes to the language learner: a narration analysis THORNE, S. L (2005) Epistemology, politics and ethics inspect sociocultural theory.

Modern Language Diary. 89/3: 393-409. Weedon, C. (1987) Feminist Practice and Poststructuralist Hesitantly. London: Blackwell. Correspondencia con steer autor: Simon Coffey Lecturer cage up Modern Foreign Languages Education Fork of Education and Professional Studies. King’s College London. Franklin-Wilkins Holdings (Waterloo Bridge Wing).

Waterloo Course of action. [email protected] 160 Revista Complutense furnish Educación Vol. 18 Núm. 2 (2007) 145-160